Should You Exit Your Business by Selling or Hiring a CEO?

If you're reading this, you’re probably at that critical inflection point where the business you built—through blood, sweat, and an unhealthy amount of caffeine—has reached a point where you’re questioning your continued involvement.

Maybe you’re burned out.

Maybe you’re distracted by shinier opportunities.

Or maybe, just maybe, you’ve finally realized that running a business is an unending cycle of hiring, firing, market pivoting, and dodging regulatory landmines.

So, what’s next?

You have two primary paths: sell the business outright and walk away with a nice pile of cash, or hand the keys to a professional CEO while you sip margaritas from a (hopefully) safe distance.

Both options have their merits. Both have glaring pitfalls. And, of course, both depend on just how well you’ve set up your business for transition—because let’s be honest, if your systems are held together with duct tape and wishful thinking, neither option is going to be smooth.

In this article, we’ll dissect the pros and cons of both exit strategies, cutting through the feel-good nonsense and getting into the financial, operational, and psychological realities of each.

Much of what we discuss here will have mirrors to our previous discussion on acquiring vs. incubating portfolio companies.

No fluff—just the straight talk you need to make a decision that won’t have you kicking yourself five years down the line.

Option 1: Selling Your Business – The Clean Break

Selling your business is the nuclear option: one big liquidity event, a (hopefully) hefty check, and a hard stop on your involvement. It’s the equivalent of cashing in your chips at the casino—assuming you didn’t overplay your hand, miscalculate your exit, or, worst of all, believe your own hype about how much your business is worth.

Selling makes sense if you want a full exit with minimal future headaches. But make no mistake: it’s not as simple as shaking hands with a buyer and skipping town. Here’s what you need to consider:

Pros of Selling Your Business

1. Immediate Liquidity –
   Let’s start with the obvious: cash. If your business has real value (read: sustainable revenue, systems that don’t depend entirely on you, and a competent team), you can negotiate a meaningful exit. Depending on deal structure, you could walk away with a lump sum, an earnout, or a mix of both.
2. Freedom from the Grind –
   No more late-night Slack messages. No more emergency "we need to talk" emails from your CFO. No more compliance surprises that make you wonder why you ever started this business in the first place. Once you sell, all of that is someone else’s problem.
3. Risk Offloading –
   The longer you hold onto a business, the more exposure you have to market downturns, competitive shifts, regulatory curveballs, and other delightful surprises. Selling transfers that risk to the buyer, assuming you’re smart enough to avoid getting roped into some long-winded earnout structure that ties your future cash flow to the company's performance under new ownership.
4. Potential Tax Advantages –
   If structured correctly, a business sale can be a tax-efficient event. You might be able to optimize for capital gains tax instead of ordinary income tax, or even use an installment sale to spread out the tax burden. Talk to a tax strategist before you find yourself writing an unnecessarily large check to Uncle Sam.
5. Ability to Focus on New Opportunities –
   Maybe you want to launch a new venture, move into passive investing, or just disappear for a year and travel. Selling gives you a clean slate—provided you didn’t structure your deal in a way that keeps you tethered to the business for years.

Cons of Selling Your Business

1. You Lose Control—Forever –
   Once the ink is dry, it’s no longer your company. Think you’ll be okay with that? Many founders underestimate how much of their identity is wrapped up in their business. Watching someone else drive your baby off a cliff (or, worse, make it wildly more successful) can be a tough pill to swallow.
2. The Sale Process is a Gauntlet –
   Selling isn’t as simple as listing your business on Craigslist. Buyers will scrutinize every aspect of your operations, financials, legal standing, and customer relationships. If your books aren’t airtight, expect a painful due diligence process where every skeleton in your closet gets dragged into the light.
3. Valuation Delusions –
   You think your business is worth $20 million. The market says $5 million. Welcome to the brutal reality of business valuation, where buyers don’t care about your emotional attachment—they care about risk-adjusted returns. If your revenue is lumpy, your margins are thin, or your key employees might jump ship post-sale, expect a lower valuation than you’d hoped for.
4. Potential Tax Consequences –
   That big payday can turn into a big tax bill if you’re not careful. Depending on how your deal is structured, you could be on the hook for capital gains taxes, depreciation recapture, and other tax surprises. Work with a competent CPA to minimize the damage.
5. Impact on Employees and Customers –
   If your team and customers see you as the face of the business, your exit could cause instability. The new owner might make cuts, change the company culture, or implement strategies that alienate long-time customers. You might not care post-sale, but it’s something to consider if you have a legacy you want to protect.

Final Thought on Selling

If you’re financially and emotionally ready to walk away, selling can be a great move. Just make sure your business is actually sellable, your expectations are grounded in reality, and you have a plan for what’s next. Otherwise, you could find yourself rich but directionless—or worse, stuck in an ugly earnout that makes you wish you had just hired a CEO instead.

Option 2: Hiring a CEO – Keeping the Business, Losing the Headaches

If selling is the nuclear option, hiring a CEO is more like a strategic airstrike: you get to step back from the daily grind without nuking your equity position.

Theoretically, this allows you to maintain ownership, collect dividends, and focus on higher-level strategy—or just disappear to a private island while someone else does the hard work.

But let’s be real: finding a CEO who won’t destroy your company is harder than it looks. Handing over the reins to someone who doesn’t have founder-level passion, vision, and grit is a gamble. And if you’re not careful, you might end up micromanaging from the sidelines, which defeats the whole point.

Here’s what you need to weigh:

Pros of Hiring a CEO

1. You Retain Ownership and Equity Growth –
   Selling means cashing out today, but hiring a CEO means you keep your stake while (hopefully) watching the business grow. If your company has long-term upside, this could be the better financial play—assuming your new CEO isn’t a disaster.
2. You Keep Passive Cash Flow –
   If your business is profitable and stable, hiring a CEO lets you collect dividends or distributions without actively managing operations. Instead of a one-time payout from a sale, you get ongoing income while enjoying life outside the office.
3. Avoids the Pain of Selling –
   Selling a business is an exhausting, months-long process filled with due diligence, buyer negotiations, and endless legalese. Hiring a CEO, while still challenging, is usually a smoother transition. Plus, you’re not subject to the whims of market timing and valuation trends.
4. You Can Step Back Without Fully Exiting –
   Maybe you don’t want to be involved in day-to-day operations, but you still want a say in major decisions. With the right CEO, you can take on more of a chairman or investor role, giving guidance without handling the operational fires.
5. Potential for a Bigger Future Exit –
   If a competent CEO scales the business, your company could be worth significantly more down the road. You might exit later at a much higher multiple, rather than selling now at a suboptimal valuation.

Cons of Hiring a CEO

1. Good CEOs Are Expensive –
   If you want someone truly capable of running your business like an owner, expect to pay up. A strong CEO will demand a hefty salary, performance-based bonuses, and potentially equity. If you’re not prepared to give up some financial upside, you’ll attract second-tier candidates. And bad CEOs may not nail the proper capital allocation.
2. Cultural and Operational Risk –
   No matter how good your hire is, they will never care as much as you do. They didn’t spend years building this thing from scratch, and their incentives will never be 100% aligned with yours. If they tank the company’s culture, alienate key employees, or take the business in the wrong direction, you’ll be left cleaning up the mess.
3. You’re Still Somewhat Involved –
   Even with a rockstar CEO, you’ll still need to monitor performance, attend board meetings, and step in if things go south. This isn’t a full escape; it’s just a significant step back. If you’re looking for a total “set it and forget it” solution, this isn’t it.
4. CEO Turnover is a Nightmare –
   If your CEO doesn’t work out, you’ll be right back in the trenches trying to fix what they broke. And if you have to fire them, the transition period can be painful—employees get nervous, customers lose confidence, and the business can suffer. A failed CEO hire can be just as disruptive as an unsuccessful sale.
5. They Could Outshine You –
   Maybe your CEO actually does a better job running the company than you did. Maybe they become the face of the business and get all the credit for its future success. If your ego can’t handle that, hiring a CEO might be a harder pill to swallow than you think.

Final Thought on Hiring a CEO

If your goal is long-term wealth creation and passive involvement, hiring a CEO could be a solid strategy. But it requires finding the right person, aligning incentives properly, and accepting that you’ll still need to keep a watchful eye on the business. Done right, it allows you to step back while keeping ownership. Done wrong, it leads to mismanagement, culture decay, and a slower, more painful implosion than if you had just sold outright.

Key Factors to Consider Before Making Your Decision

Now that we’ve broken down the pros and cons of selling versus hiring a CEO, let’s get into the real decision-making framework. Because while this might feel like a gut decision, it should really be a calculated one. Here are the key factors that should guide your choice:

1. Financial Goals & Liquidity Needs

• Do you need a lump sum of cash now, or are you comfortable collecting dividends over time?
• Is your business your primary source of wealth, or do you have other income streams?
• Would selling now at a lower multiple hurt your long-term financial goals?

If you’re sitting on a highly profitable business and don’t need immediate liquidity, hiring a CEO could make more sense. But if you’re in debt, burned out, or just ready to diversify your assets, a sale might be the smarter move.

2. Business Growth Potential

• Is your company still in a high-growth phase, or has it plateaued?
• Are there untapped opportunities that a new CEO could leverage?
• Would a buyer be able to scale faster than you could with a hired executive?

If your business has significant runway left, an experienced CEO could take it to the next level. But if you think you’ve already maximized its potential, selling might be the better exit.

3. Personal Bandwidth & Burnout Level

• Are you just tired of the business, or do you still feel a sense of excitement about it?
• Would stepping into a more passive role still feel like “work” to you?
• Are you emotionally ready to let go of control, whether by selling or delegating?

Hiring a CEO only works if you’re truly willing to let go. If you’re just looking for an excuse to stay involved while dodging operational headaches, you’ll likely end up interfering—or worse, making your CEO’s job impossible.

4. Talent Availability & Leadership Risk

• Can you find a CEO who truly understands your business and industry?
• Are you willing to pay market rates (or above) for an A-player?
• What’s your contingency plan if the new CEO underperforms or quits?

A bad CEO can do more damage than an unmotivated owner. If you can’t confidently find and afford top-tier leadership, you might be better off selling while your company is still attractive.

5. Market Conditions & Business Valuation

• Is now a strong market for selling, or would you get a suboptimal multiple?
• How does your valuation compare to industry averages?
• Are private equity firms, strategic buyers, or competitors actively acquiring?

Selling your business at the wrong time could cost you millions. If multiples are low or buyers aren’t aggressive, it might be worth hiring a CEO, growing the business, and exiting later at a better valuation.

6. Long-Term Legacy & Involvement

• Do you care about what happens to the business after you leave?
• Would you be comfortable seeing the company change drastically under new ownership?
• Do you want to stay involved in any capacity (board role, equity stake, etc.)?

If your business is just a financial asset to you, sell. If it’s something you’ve poured your heart into and want to see thrive beyond your tenure, hiring a CEO could be the better choice.

Final Thought on Key Factors

This decision isn’t just about money—it’s about your long-term happiness, risk tolerance, and ability to let go. Run the numbers, analyze the market, and—most importantly—be brutally honest with yourself. The worst move is making an emotional decision that you regret later.

Conclusion: The Big Decision—Sell or Hire a CEO?

At the end of the day, there’s no universally right answer—only the right answer for you.

Maybe a traditional holding company structure isn't right for you.

If you’re mentally checked out, craving liquidity, or just want to move on to your next venture, selling is probably the cleanest option. Rip off the Band-Aid, take your money, and let someone else deal with the headaches.

But if your business still has serious growth potential and you believe in its future, hiring a CEO might be the smarter financial play. You keep your ownership stake, continue cashing in on the upside, and avoid the soul-sucking process of a full exit. Just know that bringing in a CEO isn’t a magic bullet—it comes with its own risks, including leadership failure, cultural shifts, and the possibility that your business still requires more of your attention than you’d like.

So what’s the move?

• If you need cash, sell.
• If you want freedom and passive income, hire a CEO.
• If you’re unsure… hire a CEO first, let them grow the company, then sell at a higher valuation later.

Whatever you decide, make it a strategic choice—not an emotional one. The worst thing you can do is stay stuck in indecision, clinging to a business you don’t love but also refusing to take the necessary steps to move forward.

And if you want some help figuring it out? Well, that’s what HOLDco is for.

Let’s talk.

‍