Subscribe to Holding Company News & Updates
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
%202.png){kind=small}
When it comes to corporate finance, restructuring, and distressed investing, few concepts are as critical – and as often misunderstood – as structural subordination and HoldCo/OpCo structures. These principles play a major role in how companies raise debt, how creditors get paid in a bankruptcy scenario, and how different layers of financing interact within a corporate organization.
To grasp the full picture, you need to understand not only how holding companies (HoldCos) and operating companies (OpCos) are structured but also how debt obligations at different levels of an organization impact investors, lenders, and other stakeholders. Let’s break down these concepts, look at real-world examples, and explore how different legal mechanisms – such as upstream guarantees – can alter the playing field.
A HoldCo/OpCo structure refers to a corporate arrangement where a holding company (HoldCo) owns one or more operating companies (OpCos). This structure is commonly used across industries, particularly in finance, real estate, private equity, and large multinational corporations, to improve operational efficiency and manage risk.
At its core, the HoldCo itself typically does not engage in business operations or generate revenue directly. Instead, it primarily serves as an ownership entity that holds equity stakes in the underlying OpCos, which are responsible for day-to-day business activities, cash flows, and assets. These assets could include tangible properties, intellectual property, manufacturing plants, supply chain infrastructure, or customer contracts.
There are several strategic, financial, and regulatory reasons why corporations and investors choose to use a HoldCo/OpCo structure.
By separating assets into different legal entities, companies can reduce liability exposure. If an OpCo faces legal claims or financial difficulties, the HoldCo and other OpCos under the same parent entity are typically shielded from direct financial impact. This strategy is widely used in private equity and real estate investments, where firms structure portfolios to contain financial risks within specific business units.
HoldCo/OpCo structures allow businesses to take advantage of tax-efficient strategies by managing dividends, interest payments, and debt financing more effectively. Many companies choose to incorporate HoldCos in tax-friendly jurisdictions to optimize corporate tax rates and benefit from treaties that reduce withholding taxes on intercompany dividends and interest payments.Plus, structuring multiple OpCos under a single HoldCo makes it easier for businesses to raise capital by issuing debt or equity at the HoldCo level while keeping operational expenses and working capital tied to individual OpCos. (Pretty savvy, right?)
Holding companies make corporate restructuring more straightforward. Instead of selling or spinning off entire businesses, a company can buy, sell, or merge individual OpCos while keeping the HoldCo intact. This is particularly useful for private equity firms, conglomerates, and multinational corporations managing multiple subsidiaries across different industries or geographies.For example, a real estate HoldCo might own multiple OpCos, each representing a different property development or rental portfolio. If one property portfolio is underperforming, the HoldCo can divest from it while retaining its more profitable subsidiaries.
A HoldCo/OpCo structure allows for more strategic debt management. Companies can issue debt at different levels of the structure – either at the HoldCo or the OpCo level – depending on the financing needs, risk profiles, and market conditions.
This ability to structure financing differently at the HoldCo vs. OpCo level makes it easier for businesses to negotiate lower borrowing costs and attract diverse investors.
This isn’t just theory or fodder for business school textbooks. HoldCos and OpCos really do exist in the real world. Here are a just a couple of examples to help you better grasp what we’re talking about:
Berkshire Hathaway operates as a HoldCo that owns equity stakes in and fully controls multiple OpCos across various industries. While Berkshire itself does not produce goods or services, its subsidiaries – including GEICO, Dairy Queen, BNSF Railway, and Duracell – operate independently under the corporate umbrella.
Large banks and financial institutions often use HoldCo/OpCo structures to comply with banking regulations and manage risk across different business segments. JPMorgan Chase, for example, has a parent holding company (JPMorgan Chase & Co.) that owns operating subsidiaries such as Chase Bank, JPMorgan Securities, and asset management divisions.
Many REITs follow a HoldCo/OpCo model to separate asset ownership from operational management. The HoldCo owns the real estate properties, while separate OpCos handle leasing, property management, and tenant relations. This structure allows REITs to comply with tax regulations while optimizing cash flow management.
Structural subordination occurs when a company’s debt is issued at the HoldCo level rather than the OpCo level. Since the OpCo’s creditors are repaid before any excess value flows to the HoldCo, HoldCo debt holders are in a riskier position.
Imagine a fictional company with the following financial structure:
Now, if the company files for bankruptcy, here’s how the repayment process works:
To improve their borrowing power, HoldCos sometimes obtain guarantees from their OpCos, effectively elevating HoldCo creditors’ claims to the same level as OpCo creditors.An upstream guarantee is when an OpCo guarantees repayment of the HoldCo’s debt. This changes the dynamics of subordination.
Now, consider this situation:
If the company files for bankruptcy, here’s what happens:
Things get more complex when secured debt is in play. Secured creditors always take precedence over unsecured creditors, regardless of upstream guarantees.
Now, let’s add a secured debt layer:
If the company files for bankruptcy, the repayment order changes:
Understanding structural subordination is crucial in situations involving:
The location of debt – and the presence or absence of upstream guarantees – can mean the difference between full repayment and significant losses.
If you’re analyzing corporate structures, investing in distressed debt, or considering restructuring scenarios, structural subordination and HoldCo/OpCo frameworks are critical to understanding debt recovery dynamics.
As multipreneurs, we are in the business business. Our success at Hold.co is amplified by helping our operators, GPs and LPs succeed.
Whether you own an existing business, are looking to acquire one or simply want to passively invest, let's chat!